Electrical Machines · Synchronous Machines

Synchronous vs Induction Motors: Weighing Pros & Cons

Dr. Mithun Mondal BITS Pilani, Hyderabad Campus Electrical Machines

Demonstrative Video

SECTION 01

Merits and Demerits of Synchronous Motor

Merits:

  • The ease with which the power factor can be controlled.

    • An over-excited synchronous motor having a leading power factor can be operated in parallel with induction motors and other power apparatus operating at lagging power factors, thereby improving the power factor of the supply system.

  • The speed is constant and independent of load.

    • This characteristic is mainly of use when the motor is required to drive another alternator to generate a supply at a different frequency as in frequency changers.

  • Electro-magnetic power varies linearly with the voltage.

  • These motors can be constructed with wider air gaps than induction motors, which make them better mechanically.

  • These motors usually operate at higher efficiencies, especially in the low-speed unity pf ranges.

Demerits:
  • The cost per kW output is generally higher than that of an IM.

  • It requires DC excitation which must be supplied from external source.

  • SM is inherently not self-starting motor and needs some arrangement for its starting and synchronising.

  • It cannot be used for variable speed jobs as there is no possibility of speed adjustment.

  • It cannot be started under load and Its starting torque is zero.

  • It has a tendency to hunt.

  • It may fall out of synchronism and stop when over-loaded.

  • Collector rings and brushes are required.

  • For some purposes synchronous motors are not desirable as for driving shafts in small work-shops having no other power available for starting and in cases where frequent starting or strong starting torque is required.

SECTION 02

Comparison : \(3\phi\) Synchronous and Induction Motors

application
Application