Electrical Machines · Fundamentals

Magnetic and Electric Circuit Analogy

Part 1 · Principles of Energy Conversion — MMF drives flux through reluctance as EMF drives current through resistance, with some important differences.

Prof. Mithun Mondal Engineering Devotion Digital Textbook
i Learning Objectives

By the end of this chapter you should be able to:

  • State the quantities, symbols and units of magnetic circuits.

  • Map each magnetic quantity to its electric-circuit counterpart and write the "Ohm's law" of magnetic circuits.

  • Explain where the analogy breaks down.

  • Solve a simple series magnetic circuit with an air gap.

Demonstrative Video

Section 1

Quantities and Units

TermSymbolUnit
Flux density\(B\)tesla (T)
Flux\(\Phi\)weber (Wb)
Flux linkage\(\lambda\)volt-second (Wb-turn)
Current\(i\)ampere (A)
Field intensity\(H\)ampere per metre (A/m)
Permeability\(\mu\)henry per metre (H/m)
MMF\(F\)ampere-turn (AT)
Permeance\(P\)henry (H)
Reluctance\(S\) or \(\mathcal{R}\)per henry (1/H, AT/Wb)
Inductance\(L\)henry (H)
Current or field into the page\(\otimes\)—
Current or field out of the page\(\odot\)—
Section 2

The Analogy

Electric and magnetic circuits side by side
Electric and magnetic circuits.
Equivalent quantities
Corresponding quantities.
Electric circuitMagnetic circuit
EMF \(E\) (V)MMF \(F = NI\) (AT)
Current \(I\) (A)Flux \(\Phi\) (Wb)
Resistance \(R = \rho l/A\)Reluctance \(S = l/(\mu_0\mu_rA)\)
Conductance \(G = 1/R\)Permeance \(P = 1/S\)
Current density \(J\)Flux density \(B\)
Electric field \(E\) (V/m)Magnetic field \(H\) (AT/m)
Conductivity \(\sigma\)Permeability \(\mu\)
\(I = E/R\)\(\Phi = F/S\)
Φ
Ohm's Law for Magnetic Circuits
\(\Phi = \dfrac{F}{S} = \dfrac{NI}{l/(\mu_0\mu_rA)}\). Series reluctances add, and parallel permeances add.
Series magnetic circuit analogy
Series magnetic circuit and its electric analogue.
Parallel magnetic circuit analogy
Parallel magnetic circuit and its electric analogue.
Section 3

Where the Analogy Breaks Down

AspectElectric circuitMagnetic circuit
What happensCurrent (electrons) actually flows.Flux does not flow. It is set up as molecular magnets align.
InsulatorsMany near-perfect insulators exist (glass, air, rubber).There is no magnetic insulator. Flux is set up even in air, rubber or glass with enough MMF, hence leakage.
Linearity\(R\) is nearly constant (it changes slightly with temperature).\(S\) varies with \(B\), because \(\mu_r\) changes greatly with saturation.
EnergyEnergy is dissipated as heat continuously while current flows.Energy is needed only to establish the flux. Once set up, a steady flux needs no energy (apart from losses in the coil).
1 Worked Example — Ring with an air gap

Problem. An iron ring has a mean length of 0.5 m, a cross-section of 4 cm² and \(\mu_r = 800\), with a 2 mm air gap. A 500-turn coil must produce a flux of 0.4 mWb. Find the MMF and current, neglecting leakage and fringing.

\[S_{iron} = \frac{0.5}{4\pi\times10^{-7}\times800\times4\times10^{-4}} = 1.24\times10^6\ \text{AT/Wb}\]
\[S_{gap} = \frac{2\times10^{-3}}{4\pi\times10^{-7}\times4\times10^{-4}} = 3.98\times10^6\ \text{AT/Wb}\]
\[F = \Phi(S_{iron} + S_{gap}) = 0.4\times10^{-3}\times5.22\times10^6 = 2089\ \text{AT}, \qquad I = \frac{2089}{500} = 4.18\ \text{A}\]

The 2 mm gap needs over three times the MMF of 0.5 m of iron.

Section 4

Chapter Review

Multiple-Choice Questions
  1. MCQ 1. The magnetic analogue of resistance is
    (a) permeance (b) reluctance (c) inductance (d) permeability

    Show answer
    (b) reluctance.
  2. MCQ 2. The unit of reluctance is
    (a) AT (b) AT/Wb (c) Wb/AT (d) H

    Show answer
    (b) AT/Wb, which is the same as 1/H.
  3. MCQ 3. Reluctance of iron is not constant because
    (a) the length changes (b) μr varies with B (c) the area changes (d) temperature is fixed

    Show answer
    (b).
Conceptual Questions
  1. Why is leakage flux unavoidable while leakage current can be made negligible?

  2. Why does a small air gap dominate the reluctance of a magnetic circuit?