Electrical Machines · Synchronous Machines

Methods of Determining Voltage Regulation

Part 5 · Synchronous Machines — the direct test for small machines, and the EMF, MMF and Potier constructions for large ones.

Prof. Mithun Mondal Engineering Devotion Digital Textbook
i Learning Objectives

By the end of this chapter you should be able to:

  • Carry out the direct-loading test for regulation and state its limitation.

  • Describe the tests needed for the indirect methods: \(R_a\), the OCC, the SCC and the ZPF curve.

  • Perform the EMF, MMF and Potier (ZPF) constructions step by step.

  • Explain why the EMF method is pessimistic and the MMF method optimistic.

Demonstrative Video

Section 1

Definition

The voltage regulation of an alternator is the rise in terminal voltage when full load is removed, with field current and speed held constant, divided by the rated terminal voltage:

\[\%\,\text{V.R.} = \frac{E_0 - V}{V}\times100\]

The change depends not only on the size of the load but also strongly on its power factor.

Terminal voltage versus load current at different power factors
Terminal voltage against load current for lagging, unity and leading power factors.
Section 2

Direct Method (Small Machines)

  1. Drive the alternator at \(N_s\) and adjust the field to give rated terminal voltage \(V\).

  2. Adjust the load until the wattmeter and ammeter show rated values at the desired power factor.

  3. Throw off the entire load, keeping speed and field current constant.

  4. Read the open-circuit voltage \(E_0\) and calculate the regulation.

For large machines, supplying and absorbing full-load power at the right power factor is prohibitively expensive, so the indirect methods are used.

Section 3

Tests for the Indirect Methods

  • Armature resistance \(R_a\), by direct measurement (voltmeter–ammeter or bridge), usually corrected for operating temperature and skin effect.

  • Open-circuit characteristic (OCC): EMF per phase against field current at \(N_s\).

  • Short-circuit characteristic (SCC): armature current against field current with the terminals shorted. It is a straight line because the core is unsaturated.

  • Zero-power-factor (ZPF) curve: for the Potier method, terminal voltage against field current while the machine delivers full-load current to a purely inductive load.

Test circuit for regulation
Test arrangement for the OC and SC tests.
Section 4

EMF (Synchronous-Impedance) Method

OCC and SCC for the EMF method
Finding Zs from the OCC and SCC.

At any field current, the OCC gives \(E_1\) and the SCC gives \(I_1\), so

\[Z_s = \frac{E_1}{I_1}, \qquad X_s = \sqrt{Z_s^2 - R_a^2}, \qquad E_0 = \sqrt{(V\cos\phi + IR_a)^2 + (V\sin\phi \pm IX_s)^2}\]
Why it is pessimistic. \(Z_s\) is measured at low, unsaturated excitation, so it comes out larger than its value at normal voltage. Armature reaction is also lumped in with \(X_L\) instead of being treated separately. The predicted regulation is therefore higher than the actual value.
Section 5

MMF (Ampere-Turn) Method

This is the converse of the EMF method: the leakage-reactance drop is treated as if it were an additional armature reaction. The field current needed on full load is the phasor sum of two parts:

  • \(I_{f1}\) (\(OA\)): from the OCC, the field current giving \(V\) (or \(V + IR_a\cos\phi\)) on no load.

  • \(I_{f2}\) (\(OC\)): from the SCC, the field current needed to circulate full-load current on short circuit. On short circuit the power factor is almost zero lagging, so this field current is used entirely to overcome armature reaction, which is wholly demagnetising, plus the small reactance drop.

MMF method construction
OCC and SCC for the MMF method.
MMF phasor addition
Phasor addition of field currents.

Draw \(AB = OC\) at \((90° + \phi)\) to \(OA\) for a lagging load. The resultant \(OB\) is the total field current, and the OCC gives the corresponding \(E_0\):

\[I_f = OB = \sqrt{(I_{f1} + I_{f2}\sin\phi)^2 + (I_{f2}\cos\phi)^2}\]

Because the MMFs are added on an unsaturated basis, this method gives regulation lower than the actual value. It is optimistic.

1 Worked Example — MMF method

Problem. For an alternator, \(I_{f1} = 10\) A gives rated voltage of 3.81 kV/phase on the OCC, and \(I_{f2} = 8\) A circulates full-load current on short circuit. At 16.1 A the OCC gives 4.40 kV/phase. Find the regulation at 0.8 p.f. lagging.

\[I_f = \sqrt{(10 + 8\times0.6)^2 + (8\times0.8)^2} = 16.1\ \text{A}\]
\[\%\,\text{V.R.} = \frac{4.40 - 3.81}{3.81}\times100 = 15.5\,\%\]
Section 6

ZPF (Potier Triangle) Method

The Potier method separates the leakage-reactance drop from the armature-reaction effect. It uses the OCC and the full-load ZPF curve (not the SCC) and gives the most accurate results of the three methods.

△
Principle
\(E_0 = [V + I_a(R_a + jX_L)] + \text{armature-reaction effect}\), for lagging loads
Potier triangle construction
Potier triangle between the OCC and the ZPF curve.
Potier phasor diagram
Phasor diagram from the Potier construction.

Construction

  1. Point \(A\) on the ZPF curve is the short-circuit point (zero voltage, full-load current). \(OA\) is the field current that overcomes demagnetising armature reaction and balances the \(X_L\) drop at full load.

  2. Point \(B\) is a ZPF point at rated voltage, where the wattmeter reads zero.

  3. From \(B\), draw \(BH\) equal and parallel to \(OA\).

  4. From \(H\), draw \(HD\) parallel to the initial straight part of the OCC (the air-gap line), meeting the OCC at \(D\). \(BHD\) is the Potier triangle.

  5. Drop \(DE \perp BH\). Then \(DE = IX_L\) (the leakage-reactance drop), \(BE\) is the field current that overcomes armature reaction at full load, and \(EH\) balances the leakage drop.

  6. Form \(E = V + jIX_L\) (neglecting \(R_a\)) and read its field current \(OF\) from the OCC.

  7. Add the armature-reaction field current \(BE\) as a phasor at the appropriate angle to obtain the total field current, then read \(E_0\) from the OCC.

Section 7

Comparison of Methods

MethodDataAccuracy
DirectActual loadExact, small machines only
EMFOCC, SCC, \(R_a\)Pessimistic (too high)
MMFOCC, SCC, \(R_a\)Optimistic (too low)
ZPF (Potier)OCC, ZPF curve, \(R_a\)Most accurate
Section 8

Common Mistakes

  • Drawing \(HD\) parallel to the saturated part of the OCC. It must be parallel to the initial straight (air-gap) line.

  • Using the SCC in the Potier method. Potier needs the ZPF curve. Only its zero-voltage point coincides with the SC test.

  • Adding field currents arithmetically in the MMF method. They are phasors displaced by \(90° + \phi\).

Section 9

Chapter Review

Multiple-Choice Questions
  1. MCQ 1. The Potier triangle gives the
    (a) synchronous reactance (b) leakage reactance drop and armature-reaction field current (c) armature resistance (d) efficiency

    Show answer
    (b).
  2. MCQ 2. The SCC of an alternator is a straight line because
    (a) the core is saturated (b) the core is unsaturated on short circuit (c) \(R_a\) is large (d) the speed varies

    Show answer
    (b). The net air-gap flux is small on short circuit.
  3. MCQ 3. Which method uses a purely inductive full-load test?
    (a) EMF (b) MMF (c) ZPF (d) Direct

    Show answer
    (c) ZPF.
Conceptual Questions
  1. Why is the short-circuit power factor of an alternator almost zero lagging?

  2. Explain each side of the Potier triangle.

  3. Why does the actual regulation lie between the EMF-method and MMF-method values?