3-Phase Power Measurement with Two-Wattmeter Method

Demonstrative Video


Introduction

  • instrument for measuring the average (or real) power (\(\mathrm{P}\)) in single-phase circuits.

  • \[\begin{aligned} P_1 & = P_2 = P_3 \\ \Rightarrow ~ \mathrm{P_T} & = 3\times P_1 \end{aligned}\]
    balanced system. in a A can measure
  • two or three single-phase wattmeter required

  • : even load balanced or unbalanced, star or delta.
    image
  • \[\text{Total power} = P_1 + P_2 + P_3\]
    system where the power factor is constantly changing. well-suited for power measurement in a
  • The \(o\) reference or common point arbitrarily selected

  • For star connection, \(o\) can be neutral point and for delta, it can be any point.

  • If \(o\) is connected to \(b\), the voltage coil in \(W_2\) reads zero, hence \(W_2=0\).

  • \(W_2\) is not necessary and 2-watt meters are sufficient to measure total 3-phase power.

  • Most commonly used for \(3-\phi\) power measurement.

  • The two wattmeters must be properly connected to any two phases
    image
  • The current coil of each watt meter measures the line current

  • The respective voltage coil is connected between the line and the third line and measures the line voltage.

  • \(\pm\) terminal of voltage coil is connected to the line to which the corresponding current coil is connected.

  • The individual watt-meters no longer read the power taken by any particular phase

  • \[\boxed{\mathrm{Total ~3\phi ~power} = P_1 + P_2 \Leftarrow~\text{Algebraic sum}}\]
    -connected, balanced or unbalanced. - or The total average power absorbed by the load, regardless of whether it is
  • Consider a balanced \(\mathrm{Y}\) connected load, \(abc\) sequence and load impedance \(\mathbf{Z_Y} = Z_Y\angle \theta\)

    image

  • voltage leads the current by \(\theta~\Rightarrow~pf = \cos\theta\)

  • Recall: line voltage is \(30^{\circ}\) ahead of the corresponding phase voltage

  • Total phase difference between phase current \(\mathbf{I_a}\) and line voltage \(\mathrm{V_{ab}}\) is \(\theta + 30^{\circ}\)

  • \[\begin{aligned} P_1 & =\operatorname{Re}\left[\mathbf{V}_{a b} \mathbf{I}_a^*\right]=V_{a b} I_a \cos \left(\theta+30^{\circ}\right)=V_L I_L \cos \left(\theta+30^{\circ}\right) \\ P_2 & =\operatorname{Re}\left[\mathbf{V}_{c b} \mathbf{I}_c^*\right]=V_{c b} I_c \cos \left(\theta-30^{\circ}\right)=V_L I_L \cos \left(\theta-30^{\circ}\right) \\ \end{aligned}\]
    are: and Power
  • \[\begin{aligned} \cos (A+B) & =\cos A \cos B-\sin A \sin B \\ \cos (A-B) & =\cos A \cos B+\sin A \sin B \end{aligned}\]
    Using trigonometric rules
  • \[\begin{aligned} P_1+P_2 & =V_L I_L\left[\cos \left(\theta+30^{\circ}\right)+\cos \left(\theta-30^{\circ}\right)\right] \\ &=V_L I_L\left(\cos \theta \cos 30^{\circ}-\sin \theta \sin 30^{\circ}\right. \\ & \left.\quad+\cos \theta \cos 30^{\circ}+\sin \theta \sin 30^{\circ}\right) \\ &=V_L I_L 2 \cos 30^{\circ} \cos \theta\\ &=\sqrt{3} V_L I_L \cos \theta ~ \Leftarrow 2\cos 30^{\circ} = \sqrt{3} \\ & \boxed{P_T = P_1 + P_2 = \sqrt{3} V_L I_L \cos \theta} \end{aligned}\]
    Total real power:
  • \[\begin{aligned} P_1-P_2= & V_L I_L\left[\cos \left(\theta+30^{\circ}\right)-\cos \left(\theta-30^{\circ}\right)\right] \\ = & V_l I_L\left(\cos \theta \cos 30^{\circ}-\sin \theta \sin 30^{\circ}\right. \\ & \left.\quad-\cos \theta \cos 30^{\circ}-\sin \theta \sin 30^{\circ}\right) \\ = & -V_L I_L 2 \sin 30^{\circ} \sin \theta ~ \Leftarrow 2\sin 30^{\circ} =1 \\ P_2-P_1= & V_L I_L \sin \theta \end{aligned}\]
    Similarly:
  • \[\boxed{Q_T = \sqrt{3}\left(P_2-P_1\right)}\]
    Total reactive power:
  • \[S_T = \sqrt{P_T^2+Q_T^2}\]
    Total apparent power:
  • \[\boxed{\tan\theta = \dfrac{Q_T}{P_T} =\sqrt{3}\cdot \dfrac{P_2-P_1}{P_2+P_1} }\]
    To determine pf angle:
  • From \(\tan\theta ~ \Rightarrow ~\theta ~ \Rightarrow ~\cos\theta = pf\)

  • 2-watt-meter method provides \(P_T\), \(Q_T\), and pf also

  • \[\begin{aligned} \text{If}~ & P_2 = P_1 \Rightarrow~\text{Resistive}\\ \text{If}~ & P_2 > P_1 \Rightarrow~\text{Inductive}\\ \text{If}~ & P_2 < P_1 \Rightarrow~\text{Capacitive} \end{aligned}\]
    Determine the load characteristics:
  • The two-wattmeter method cannot be used for power measurement in a \(3-\phi\) four-wire system unless neutral current is zero.